Choosing Between Speedybee Mario 5 and Axisflying Manta 5 for FPV
Hello! I am starting my first build and I am picking between these two frames: Speedybee Mario 5 o4 pro dc version, Axisflying Manta 5 se v2 dc version. I am planning to do cinematics and freestyle. Which one is actually better for my build?
A
5sett.
If you want to do cinematic both are a great choise but for more intense freestyle id look for a true x or squished x frame from a popular company. A dead cat frame like these won't handle the best for freestyle.
👍 2
Rispondi
5sett.
to be fair, my first 5" was a violator 2 dc and it did all the freestyle I could handle for a good while, its still my go to for 5" cinematic. There are other factors that will change flight characteristics more than the format, like would you have to carry an action camera that adds ~400g on an x vs having a dc that just uses the o4 pro. That being said, several years and +1000 hours in and Im building an analog kayoudur because its very clear that I wont be able to fly hardcore freestyle in real life at this level without it.
👍 2
Rispondi
5sett.
we need more information, like what motors are you using. both are fine frames, so with just this info: whichever you can get the most spare parts for and whichever will give you the best thrust to weight ratio
👍 2
Rispondi
5sett.
Autore
I am planning to use a Speedybee F405 V5 stack with a T Motor VELOX V2306.5 1950KV 5" motors. I think I am actually a little more to cinematic.
👍 1
Rispondi
A
5sett.
Dead cat will work fairly well for freestyle and true x will work great for cinematic "not perfect but very flyable" so go with whatever your more interested in. If you want something between squished x is great.
Rispondi
A
5sett.
I just wanted to clarify from my previous response.
Rispondi
A
5sett.
Both easy to build in frames I belive but the manta will give you more space if that matters.
Rispondi
A
5sett.
Personaly if i were to build a o4 freestyle drone id go with the o4 x shape mario 5 over the manta as it is more popular / more talked about and has good things said about it.
Rispondi
5sett. (modificato 5sett.)
https://pyrodrone.com/collections/motors/products/t-motor-velox-veloce-v2306-5-v2-1950kv
take a look at the chart they have for those specific motors. I know it might be complicated to read, but this info determines a lot of how your build will fly. At 100% throttle with 3 blade 5" props, those motors produce ~6400g of total thrust, take that number and divide it by the theoretical total weight of the build, including battery, action cam, etc. This will tell you your thrust to weight ratio, which tells you a lot about how it will fly. you want a 4:1 minimum for slow flight, no evasive maneuvers, 8:1 or more for freestyle. A 700g total build would be around 9:1, which is pretty decent. Also look at the total max amps for all 4 motors, you want to make sure your esc and batteries are rated for the amount of current that will flow through them (preferably with a decent amount of headroom).
Rispondi
A
Lascia un commento